Talking Stone Rock Art Coso America USA Documentary Film

Latest News

BRADSHAW FOUNDATION - LATEST NEWS

 
Romanian rock art - as old as Chauvet?
2011 Dec 04

Share

A VERY ANCIENT ART IN RUMANIA - THE COLIBOAIA DATES
Published in INORA 61, 2011, pp. 1-3


A rhinoceros head drawn with charcoal in the Coliboaia cave (Rumania). Photo Jean Clottes

An account of the discovery of paintings in the Coliboaia cave in the Natural Park of Mounts Apuseni, department of Bihor, Rumania, was published in INORA (Besesek et al. 2010).

A French team, including two spelunkers (Marcel Meyssonnier and Valerie Plichon), a paleontologist who is a specialist of cave bears (Michel Phlippe), a prehistorian (Francoise Prudhomme) and two specialists of cave art (Jean Clottes and Bernard Gely), managed to reach the paintings on 16 May 2010. They established their authenticity. The team received logistical help from associations Speodava Ştei, Speowest Arad, France-Roumanie Speleologie, Orgnac - Grand Site de France, Grotte et Musee regional de Prehistoire (Region Rhone-Alpes) and the Apuseni Natural Park under the coordination of Viorel Lascu.


Undetermined animal dated by 14C in the Coliboaia cave (Rumania). Photo Jean Clottes

From the themes represented and the appearance of the animals, the initial hypothesis proposed for the dating of the drawings from seeing the first photographs was that they belonged to an ancient period of cave art, to the Gravettian or the Aurignacian (i.e. between 25,000 and 35,000 BP) (ibid.: 11). Another fact seeming to support the hypothesis was the association of a bone planted in the ground to a cave bear skull next to it, as similar examples were known from the Chauvet cave. During our May 2010 expertise, we could see that in fact the Coliboaia bones had been handled and deposited there in modern times, probably by spelunkers before the art was discovered. In the conclusion of their report, the two specialists of cave art however attributed - on stylistic grounds - the drawings they had long examined to the earliest period of cave art.

Calin Ghemis, an archaeologist with the Oradea Tanii Crisurilor Museum (Rumania), lifted two samples, the first directly from the extremity of a line in the interior of the head of one of the undetermined animals (a feline or a horse which had been scratched by bats); the other one being a piece of charcoal found quite close to that animal on a ledge below.

Finally, two very ancient dates have just been obtained by the 14C method with Artemis (LMC-14, CEA, Saclay) by the Laboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l'Environnement at Gif-sur-Yvette (LSCE/UVSQ, France) (Valladas et al. 2001). The one for the animal is 27,870 +/- 250 BP, i.e. 31,450/32,820 years Cal BP (GifA11002/SacA23417). The other one, from the piece of charcoal is 31,640 +/- 390 BP, i.e. 35,120/36,780 years cal BP (GifA11001/SacA23416) (Reimer et al. 2009). Whatever the reason for the difference between these dates, they put the Coliboaia art within the most ancient period of cave art.

The chronological difference between the two dates may be due to two different causes. If it is indeed a factual difference, there would then be two times of frequentation of the cave at an interval of 3,000 to 4,000 years. This is not impossible as, when we did our expertise, we had noted that the undetermined animal (89cm long and 39cm high) (Fig.) looked fresher than several of its neighbours and was not calcited. A few small pieces of charcoal were on the ledge below it: one of them gave the older date.

Another possibility would be that the two samples dated would be contemporaneous but that the one from the animal, minute for conservation necessity, would have kept a feeble contamination in recent carbon after chemical treatment, which would underestimate its age. A contamination making the other sample older than it should be is out of the question. Pending other analyses in the future, the small number of figures, their stylistic unity and the spatial closeness of the samples make us favour the second hypothesis rather than the first.

Those dates are also interesting from a methodological point of view. They confirm our preliminary diagnosis based on thematic and stylistic grounds, thus showing that this kind of chrono-cultural evaluation, despite all the doubts it raises these days, may be justified, particularly if we cannot get direct datings.

It is the first time that such an ancient art, comparable to that in the Chauvet cave, has been discovered and dated in Central Europe. Another painted cave, Cuciulat, has long been known in Rumania (Carciumaru 1988). Even if the style and technique (in flat tint) of the two identified animals (a horse and a possible feline) differ from the art in Coliboaia and if the chronology of Cuciulat may also be different, it is obvious that the discovery of Coliboaia reinforces the interest of Cuciulat, an undoubtedly Palaeolithic cave as its discovered had long said (ibid.).

With the Coliboaia dates a commonality of cultural practices and probably of beliefs from those very early times all over Europe is now apparent. This is not a mean result.

Jean CLOTTES, Bernard GELY, Calin GHEMIS, Evelyne KALTNECKER,
Viorel-Traian LASCU, Christophe MOREAU, Michel PHILIPPE, Francoise PRUD'HOMME, Helene VALLADAS

To subscribe to INORA to view the full paper click here



Homepage About the Foundation Contact Us News Articles Twitter Travel Index About the Expeditions Forthcoming Expeditions Bespoke Expeditions Enquire Practical Information History of Exploration Welcome to the iShop Film Downloads DVD's Sculpture Prints Clothing Messenger Bag eBooks INORA Downloads About iLecture Films Shipping & Handling iLectures In Conversation Video Stories Travel Films Read the reviews Join the free Mailing List Friends of the Foundation Archive Index World's Oldest Rock Art Africa Documentary Films South Africa RARI Giraffe Carvings Niger Namibia Western Central Africa Africa Paintings Gallery Tanzania The Tuareg People Tuareg Salt Caravans Gilf Kebir Archive Index San Rock Art Paintings San Bushman San Rock Art Film Origins Centre Johannesburg Archive Index Arizona Baja California Coso Range Nevada Oregon Territory Australia Archive Index Introduction Bradshaw Paintings Kimberley Region The Unambal Hugh Brown Leif Thiele Gallery Dan Clark Grahame Walsh Ian Wilson Bradshaws / Gwion Gwion Archive Index Introduction Origins of the British Stonehenge Sounds of Stonehenge The British Museum British Isles Megaliths Gower Peninsula Rock Art Mendip Hills Prehistory Northumberland Rock Art Red Lady of Paviland Stone Age Mammoth Abattoir Archive Index Yinchuan Museum Rock Art Festival Field Trip Gallery Itinerant Creeds Inner Mongolia & Ningxia Vanishing Civilization Life in Rock Art (PDF) Tibet Tibet Photographs Dazu Rock Carvings Tiger Motif Archive Index Chauvet Cave Lascaux Cave Niaux Cave Cosquer Cave Portable Art Research Paper Tuc d'Audoubert Bison Dr. Jean Clottes Index Introduction Cave Paintings Gallery Visiting the Chauvet Cave Return to Chauvet Cave Investigating the Cave Venus & Sorcerer Werner Herzog Film Chauvet Publications India Archive Index Rock Art Central India Pachmarhi Hills India Rock Art Gallery Middle East Archive Index Middle East Inroduction Rock Art of Iran Rock Art of Saudi Arabia United Arab Emirates Rock Art Ancient Geometry Middle East Colonisation Tanum Rock Art Museum Thor Heyerdahl Archive Index Introduction America's Oldest Art? Pedra Furada Bolivian Rock Art Campeche Island - Brazil Checta Petroglyphs - Peru Cueva de las Manos Santa Catarina Island - Brazil Rock Art in Britain Campeche Rock Art Petroglyphs El Salvador - Corinto Cave Hand Rock Art Paintings Tibetan Rock Art United Arab Emirates Uzbekistan Yinchuan Rock Art Museum Introduction Ice Age Art Gallery Claire Artemyz Jill Cook Interview Cycladic Introduction Cycladic Gallery Introduction Geometric Signs Chart Research Methodology Geometric Signs in France Sign Types/Countries/Regions Bibliography Ancient Symbols in Rock Art Newsletter Archive Download Issues Introduction Genetic Map Professor Stephen Oppenheimer Further Reading Origins of the British BBC Documentary Origins Index Origins Overview 13 Big Questions Stanley Ambrose Homo Floresiensis Herto Skulls Homo Dmanisi Liujiang Skull Introduction Sentinels in Stone Easter Island Rock Art Birdman Cult / Motif Sea & Marine Creatures Design & Motifs Dr Georgia Lee Easter Island Map Contemporary Art Glossary Conclusion Thor Heyerdahl Introduction When & Who Built It? How Was It Built? The Area Sounds of Stonehenge Meaning of a Pyramid Pyramid Studies Pyramid Superstructure Pyramid Substructure Pyramid Preparations Pyramid Building Saqqara Nabil Swelim Temples of Malta and Gozo Research in the Caucasus The Keselo Foundation Homo Dmanisi Ancient Toolmakers Index Introduction Descent into the Cave The Decorated Caves Shamanistic Experience Spring Initiation Rites Summary Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Professor John P. Miller Motif: Eternal Index Han Meilin Bruce Radke Christian Tuki Gordon Ellis-Brown Site Map Search the Website Glossary of Terms & Definition Podcast on iTunes List of Research Papers Other Websites Contact the Foundation